It is quite difficult to remove, I don't know why some refer to it as tubing mascara. Having used other tubing mascaras, this one is clearly not. However, it has very good hold, and provides impressive length and volume.

I belong to the category of consumers who will buy any mascara without noticing a significant difference. I read somewhere that the panorama is a "tube" mascara, meaning it doesn't smudge when you remove it, so I decided to give it a try. I think I have now found my favorite. The result is just right for everyday use.

Surprisingly very good, might need some help with another brush when applying for a more natural look but it doesn’t smudge and doesn’t flake the whole day.

It is tolerable for many hours on sensitive eyes and does not flake. It has no extraordinary effect for someone who wants a more intense makeup, but for everyday use and a more natural result, it is very good.

Good mascara that makes the eyelashes look very long but doesn't give much volume. Its biggest advantage is that it doesn't flake and stays in place until you remove your makeup.

This particular mascara should be labeled as waterproof. You apply it, and if you don't remove it, it can stay on your eye for three days without flaking and without sticking to the adjacent lashes. I hadn't worn mascara in a while, and I decided to get a brown one, and I was shocked!

Very nice mascara! The other day at a cosmetics store, they asked me which one I use, and my eyelashes look so long!

One of my favorite drugstore mascaras, it gives intense results from the first coat, lasts all day on me, and even catches the smallest eyelash. On my lashes, it gives both volume and length, separates them, and is one of the mascaras that I buy again and again.

It defines the lashes with no clumps. But, it doesn't thicken the lashes. It lasted all day with no smudging under the eye. Washing it off was a catastrophe!!!! Flakes were coming off even the next day, AND MY LASHES WERE FALLING OFF!!!!!! LASHES ON MY FACE AND PILLOW UNTIL THE NEXT DAY!!!! I THREW IT IN THE GARBAGE.

Basically I was a little disappointed with the brown mascara. It doesn't look brown at all, it's almost black.
The brush is bulky for my taste, I would prefer it to be more delicate and separate my lashes.
Otherwise, it's a good mascara.

Really excellent mascara. Impressive result with just one swipe on lashes, neither too long nor too dense. I will definitely buy it again.

For some reason, I haven't been impressed, L'Oreal generally always had great mascaras, but with this specific one, I wasn't completely satisfied.

Very good mascara, overall I am satisfied with L'Oréal mascaras. Before I had the baby roll which they discontinued, but fortunately this one is even better, it doesn't smudge around the eyelashes!!!