In this base, I needed to remove the phone case for the phone to fit by itself. I don't know what happens with the others. When the phone is clicked into place, it doesn't remain stable in the position I set due to its weight, vibrations, and the loosening of the neck which is the clamp. It somewhat leans down while driving, but I calibrate it with my hand. I do not recommend it for long distances of 100 kilometers, for example, or for aggressive-fast driving.