I've been using it for many years, it suits me better than any other pencil I've tried on my eyes. First of all, I don't tear up and it doesn't sting, and it's also quite stable even during the summer months. The only downside is that it's quite expensive, especially with daily use that will run out quickly. The price is the only reason I would resort to another brand. Other than that, it is indeed good.

Quite poor pencil quality. While it is soft and has a nice and intense black color, if you want to apply it a little lightly, you end up smudging yourself. Besides that, after about 2 hours of wearing it (at least now in the summer when it's hot), you end up going out with a smudged lower eyelid even if the application was done on the top. I wouldn't buy it again. It's not worth the money.

I bought this product twice. Brown color. The tip is hard and it hurts the eye when you apply it. It also leaves a stain on the upper eyelid, even though I have used eye primer and powder. It is also expensive, I bought it for 12€. I will not buy it again

I asked for an eyeliner because I apply it from the lower side inside the eye and they suggested this one. It is not easy to apply at all because it smudges immediately since the eye is wet. So it doesn't last at all, it's like I haven't put anything on and it gathers at the edge. As an eyeliner, it's okay but I didn't buy it for that reason. Also, I tried to do a smokey eye with the sponge applicator, it didn't work as it required a lot of pressure and I didn't want to try it again and irritate my eyelid. I am disappointed.

I haven't changed it for years now! I use it instead of eyeliner because I don't like it completely black. It has a strong effect without making the eyes look wild. Also, if you work it with the sponge that it has on the back, you achieve the perfect smokey!

Waterproof, I don't think it is as it claims, it's just a very intense black color. I didn't go crazy over it. There are so many other pencils that are cheaper!

Very good and stable pencil. It doesn't melt or run in the eyes, so we avoid the annoying smudging.

Excellent eye pencil! The color is intense and its durability is unbelievable. I tested it in the sea and it is indeed waterproof, as long as you don't rub your eyes. I will definitely choose it again in other shades.