I give 3 stars because I returned it and I don't want to do it an injustice. I can't say anything about the quality or comfort. I bought it based on the size I wear in the Silia D brand, but the box had something different written on it, so I'm not sure if this brand is what I received. I returned it because it didn't fit me. However, I want to mention the following: the specific one I received had fur inside, which is not mentioned in the description nor shown in the photos, and because it is thick, it makes it suitable only for winter. Also, possibly due to the fur, the fit was quite tight and the shoe was small for me. I'm not sure if I received the right one or something that looked similar...