I take the 2 ash blonde. I give it 5 stars because out of all the pencils I have tried, it has the longest lasting power, maybe up to 3 days, it gives a natural result, fills in the eyebrows and colors the skin in between, gives a nice shape, that's why it's my favorite and I buy it constantly. If it slips during application and before it dries, you can clean it off and it comes off without leaving a stain. It fades evenly over the course of the days.
-It runs out quickly. The brush is not convenient as it is somewhat cylindrical, especially at first it holds a lot of product... you have to remove it at the opening.