I am a delivery driver, my hands have endured a lot of cold, rain, and sun; I have had them for 3 full years, and for the price, they are top-notch. The negative after 3 years is that they have faded from the sun; from black, they have turned purple, which is okay. One rubber piece that tightens around the wrist to prevent air from getting in has torn (probably from the wrist movements on the throttle grip). I made a workaround by putting another rubber piece that I found. They don’t have any lining inside, so I don’t know how much warmer those with lining are, but these do their job just fine.