Eddie and Amy are two teenagers in love who belong to different worlds. Wanting to escape their boring lives for a while, they organize a night trip to Fear Street Forest with four other friends. As Eddie carves a heart into a tree, he and Amy discover a bag hidden inside the trunk. A bag full of hundred-dollar bills. Thousands of hundred-dollar bills. Should they take them? Should they leave them there? They ultimately decide to bury them in the pet cemetery where Eddie works. But when they realize that the robber might find them, they try to return the money. Only the money is no longer there. The trust among the six friends is shaken, and the situation becomes increasingly dangerous, as a strange wolf threatens Amy's dreams and life.