As a lightweight and comfortable shoe, it provides the promised protection. One star because... within two months, the outer part of the shoe was destroyed, resulting in a hole that went through the shoe. The inner part of the shoe also became worn out (I work as a refrigeration technician mainly in houses, not construction sites, so we're not talking about excessive wear and tear). In terms of comfort, they are great for the money, but in terms of durability, get something else for the same price